An
Insight into the Violence in the Middle East
by Yossi Amrani,
Consul General of Israel to the Pacific Northwest Region
Israel grieves the loss of life and human suffering following almost
a week of rioting and violence. The haunting images of death and pain
are excruciating for all.
This
unnecessary bloodshed was not and has never been our choice. For Israel,
making peace has always been preferable to fighting. The Israeli people
crave peace and hold life as a core value.
The
situation is all the more agonizing as the parties have reached such
a critical point in their negotiations. During the trilateral summit
hosted by President Clinton in Camp David and the few subsequent rounds
of talks in New York, Washington and in the region, Israelis and Palestinians,
with the help of the US administration, the Egyptian government and
other countries, reached a stage in which both parties had a full
understanding of the other's positions. It is regrettable that as
we advance toward peace, children are being used to promote a political
agenda.
It
must be remembered that this period had been considered a target date
to reach an accord. We must not let that opportunity slip away; we
must not give up our yearning for a comprehensive peace.
It is now our hope, especially after the meeting yesterday in Paris,
that the recent confrontations will only constitute a temporary set-back,
that Chairman Arafat will issue a call for restraint to his people,
and that our Palestinian partners will join us back at the negotiating
table and respond to the peace initiatives and proposals put forward
by the Israeli government.
In the last few months, Prime Minister Barak and his government have
made several bold political decisions, underscoring Israel's efforts
to progress on the peace track. These steps required both daring leadership
and political risks.
It
is unfortunate that instead of responding to Israel's determination
to find creative solutions and resolve core issues of the conflict
- on borders, settlements, refugees and Jerusalem - the Palestinians
decided to resort to rioting and inciting to violence, disturbingly
through the means of the official Palestinian Radio.
There
should be no misunderstanding: Under no circumstances can violence
be used as a negotiating tool. As the parties get closer to an agreement,
it is expected that disputes and points of contention should be worked
out around the negotiating table and not in street battles.
At
Camp David, Prime Minister Barak went the extra mile in raising and
offering unprecedented compromises on the issue of Jerusalem and the
Temple Mount. Our partners in peace should realize that to finally
resolve the conflict between Jews and Arabs there is a need for substantive
compromise on both sides. Throwing grenades, rocks and Molotov cocktails
cannot replace dialogue, cannot replace compromise.
Jerusalem
is the capital of the State of Israel, the place where Jews have prayed
for over 3000 years and where we finally succeeded in building our
independent homeland. Israel has always recognized it is a holy city
for Muslims, Christians and Jews. With the reunification of the city
in 1967, Israel has honored and upheld its commitment to guaranteeing
freedom of access to the holy sites for people of all faiths. In any
future agreement this right will be maintained.
When
the hostilities cease and the dust finally settles, the time will
come to clear the air and resume the process leading to a comprehensive
peace for Jews and Arabs in the Holy Land.
Israel's
public opinion will endorse a peace accord only if convinced that
our Palestinian neighbors are true partners in peace. The events of
recent weeks date back to well before the Temple Mount disturbances.
They have shaken the trust and confidence of many Israelis as regards
the Palestinians' commitment to reach what Chairman Arafat has repeatedly
called "the peace of the braves". The active involvement
in the riots of certain sectors among Israeli Arabs aggravates the
concerns of Israelis as to the degree of cooperation we can reach
with our neighbors. As much as we are willing to sacrifice for peace,
there can hardly be anyone in Israel ready to sacrifice the country
itself.
We
cherish the same land, this unique place which is sacred to so many
people around the world. We understand the Palestinian people's desires
and expectations. It is incumbent upon all to relinquish violence,
to show pragmatism and to resume negotiations. We must accept each
other's existence and rights as the reality of life - our lives -
in the Middle East and hope that there will be no more bloodshed in
the region.